5. Designs for Life: Priority Threat Management and Nature-Based Plans
SYNOPSIS:
This week we’re asking whether it’s possible to support the lifeworlds of nature with the very same tools that have caused them harm. First we’ll be joined by Lorenzo de Rosenzweig who has headed Latin America’s largest nature conservation trusts for over three decades, and then Eric Smith from the Grantham Neglected Climate Opportunities Fund and Edacious will talk about venture capital investing in nature based solutions.
I’m interested in this topic because in parallel to this podcast I invest capital in projects that regenerate nature through my vehicle Ground Effect. In that work I constantly encounter philosophical and practical tensions – namely that complex natural systems and the trillions of processes that enable life to exist can never be fully translated and priced by markets. Nature’s value is infinite. Numbers and metrics can’t tell us about the touch of rough bark or the flutter of a beetle’s wing against our skin. And because money is fungible, it can often efface all distinctions and trigger the further commodification and abstraction of a living ecology.
And yet finance can be used beneficially on behalf of nature. We can look at the maturing industry of biodiversity markets which attempt to move beyond single metrics like carbon, or debt for nature swaps, blue bonds, true cost accounting, payments for ecosystem services, and even more radical ideas like DAOs where nature owns itself. I’ve uploaded readings and resources on the Lifeworlds library for those who want to go deeper on these innovations. Perhaps then, the conversation of “finance for nature” is about finding the right balance of not letting the perfect be the enemy of the good, and acknowledging where the role of markets begins and ends in the wider spectrum of systems change.
Your browser doesn't support HTML5 audio
Money: In Service to Nature?
QUOTES:
Lorenzo de Rosenzweig
We have to work with our heart and our intelligence to bring things back slowly to how things should be.
Every morning I am grateful that I have been put by destiny and by work, in this position of being someone that eventually might become a good ancestor.
Communication is the most underused resource for conservation - everyone has a biophilic soul and we need to connect them with great stories.
Eric Smith
You have to be on the ground sitting alongside the stakeholders, and part of that process is talking to nature, and feeling.
That is the crux of systems change — reorienting financial decision-making to be more holistic in the way that it allocates resources.
I don’t think we use debt enough for many of our regenerative agriculture investments. Debt has a certain structure in terms of the patience around it that allows for very clear expectations and a very clear contract.
We are extractive from our producers. If you want to get back to improving the land, you have to return wealth back to those producers. They know the land better than anyone. They're the reason we're alive.